It's amazing to look back on the dub era from the standpoint of today, when the show is practically gone in the US, and see how fandom (particularly online) has changed in the near-decade that's gone by.
I remember looking for information on the show back in early 1996 and finding a couple of very funny and informative websites. Some, though, are hilarious only in hindsight, like a page that said "Uranus" and "Neptune" were only rumors and that not one knows what's been happening in the mythical 'SuperS' season.
One of the first ones I visited, which I'm absolutely amazed is still around, is "Sailor Moon Says: Your Daily Alternative."
http://home.mindspring.com/~anjiro/sm.html
This place still makes me laugh. (If you haven't read the parodies, go to it.) And I still have 1996 printouts (from an Okidata dot matrix) of some of the "Lita Lettermoon" Top 10 lists.
Capeboy R and I were on the "Looney" (SOS's) mailing list then too. Going over some saved e-mails from the first few months of their campaign is a trip, as the enthusiasm toward the show, and the desire to keep it on the air, is overwhelming. Not even so much toward getting the rest of the show dubbed (although that was certainly a goal); we just wanted it to
stay on TV.
Similar enthusiasm today to me seems impossible. Keeping the show on the air for most of us just isn't a big deal, and the majority of fans have been jaded over the years. It seems natural that, particularly given the hack jobs the show has suffered on US TV, few fans really want or care if it's on the air. We've all seen it so many times, after all.
If we step back, though, and look at the fandom of other 'cartoon' series, like maybe Robotech (or, bringing up what YingGirl mentioned in the OAMVG forum, Samurai Pizza Cats), they still
want their show on US TV, not because otherwise they can't watch it (I'm sure the majority of fans have it on tape already), but just to keep the show alive and for it to gain a new audience.
It seems to me that most Sailor Moon fans are different from this and in particular apathetical toward having it on the air. They're more concerned with their personal viewing situation. (E.g. "We don't care if it's on TV- we won't watch it, we don't care if it gains a new audience- big whoop, we just want a better sub version.")
I'm not making a judgement call on this- I'm not saying whether that's a good or bad thing. I'll readily admit to falling into that category often.
I'm interested in if others agree with my assessment, though.
So, particularly the old hands here, tell me what you think, and if you want to just reminisce in general about the old SM fandom, that's fine too.